Penguin Book Essay Contest

“It’s not easy being green.”

Caliban is a monster. While we have no idea of what he looked like in the original production by Shakespeare’s company, the footnote on page 17 of the Signet text suggests that his mother was a hook-like deformed creature—a cross between a female cow and a raven, and Prospero says he was “got by the devil himself.” In I, i Prospero calls him a “tortoise,” and Miranda refers to him as “a villain…I do not love to look on.” No matter the nature of his literal appearance, in Shakespeare’s world to be ugly is to be morally corrupt. Although Shakespeare understood that people who were “other,” were, after all, still human beings, (Shylock, Othello, Aaron the Moor, Richard III), black was not beautiful in the Elizabethan/Jacobean period, and if indeed Caliban is tortoise-like, “it’s not easy being green.” Racial difference is a deformity, and the inner person reflects the individual’s outer appearance. Ariel is air; Caliban is “earth.”

At the same time that he is reviled, he is also given a sympathetic back story. The island was once his; he was “king,” and when Prospero first came, he petted Caliban, taught him human speech and basic astronomy (“how/To name the big light, and how the less,/That burn by day and night”) and even let him live in Prospero’s own cell. In return, Caliban loved him and introduced him to the beauties and pitfalls of his new environment, but his inner brutish nature prevailed, and he attempted to rape Miranda, who was then, presumably, a child. Caliban is a would-be serial rapist pedophile. His “vile race… had that in’t which good natures/Could not abide to be with.”

Prospero, however, did not kill Caliban. Instead he enslaved him, and he admits to Miranda: “We cannot miss [do without] him. He does make our fire/Fetch in our wood, and serves in offices/That profit us.” Caliban is the economic engine that drives the island. His “offices” allow Prospero the leisure to pursue the studies of magic that, in return, keep Caliban in dreadful captivity. Caliban is limited in movement (“Here you sty me/In this hard rock, whiles you do keep from me/The rest o’ the island”); he is best by “cramps,” “aches,” “side-stitches,” “stripes,” and pinches “more stinging/Than bees that made ‘em.” The brutality with which his slavery is enforced matches the brutality of his nature and of his behavior, but he is, nevertheless, a chattel slave, and modern-day readers cannot help but wonder if Shakespeare was aware of the brutality of the slave trade that flourished in Islamic countries in the early seventeenth century and that Europe would spread to the New World within the next twenty years.

Before Prospero taught him “language,” Caliban was only capable of animal sounds, and while he contends that his only “profit… IS, I know how to curse,” he actually curses in iambic pentameter and, late in the play, delivers one of its most beautiful passages (“Be not afeard; the isle is full of noises,/Sounds and sweet airs that give delight and hurt not”). He also discovers in the course of the play that he can communicate with men other than his master, namely Stephano and Trinculo, who introduce him to wine and whom he first assumes are spirits come to injure him and subsequently gods. In his limited experience with human beings, he is like Miranda, but whereas she is attracted to a noble form and mind in Ferdinand, Caliban is attracted to the play’s figures of comic relief, a jester and a drunken butler, essentially lower-class working people, close in their earthiness to himself. They ply him with alcohol, and he offers to show the mysteries of the island, just as he did Prospero. In fact, he wishes to substitute his worship of them for his obedience to his old master. Prospero has kept Caliban as a slave; Stephano and Trinculo offer him the possibility of freedom. He does not, of course, understand that they are using him just as Prospero did, because he is beset by a slave mentality. He acknowledges Prospero as his master and immediately assumes that his relationship to Stephano and Trinculo must be the same, that he must kiss their feet.

It turns out, however, that he is also using them—to murder Prospero. The plot, of course, fails, and the audience last sees the revolting triumvirate drenched in “horse piss,” with Caliban renouncing his confederates and returning to his menial role. He is both a product of nature and nurture. His physical appearance and his genetic inheritance from Sycorax, his mother, and the devil, his father, lead him inexorably into lust, rape, drunkenness, and attempted murder. At the same time, however, he has been systematically reduced to servility by the white Europeans he meets, and when he attempts to assert his freedom—to be his own man—he is beaten back by magical forces beyond his control. From a twenty-first century point of view, he is a victim both of his own “otherness” and of the “otherness” that has been foisted upon him and fostered within him by a dominant culture.

In a life like Caliban’s, there are only two positives. The first is the sensitivity he shows to the natural world around him, “the thousand twangling instruments” that “hum about [his] ears” and allow him to dream of “riches/ready to drop upon” him. The second, as Robert Langbaum points out in his introduction to the Signet edition, is that at the end of the play, Prospero announces that he is going to leave the island, which means that, once again, Caliban will be its king. The audience, of course, does not see this and may not think of the story behind the play as soon as the plot ends. The possibility, however, is there. Caliban is one of Shakespeare’s beloved villains—Richard III, Macbeth, Aaron the Moor in Titus Andronicus, Edmond in King Lear, and Don John in Much Ado about Nothing. While he must be thwarted at the end of the play and cannot be forgiven, he is blessed with a level of poetic sensitivity that transcends his nature.

Read the winning essays from previous years »

For more than seventy years, Penguin has been the leading publisher of classic literature in the English-speaking world, providing readers with a global bookshelf of the best works throughout history and across genres and disciplines. Now, we are proud to host our second annual Penguin Classics Student Scholarship Essay Contest, in which five high school freshmen or sophomores can each win a $1,000 scholarship award to be used toward their higher education plus a selection of Penguin Classics Deluxe Editions for their school! Essays must be submitted by a high school English teacher on behalf of students who write an essay on one of five topics for this year’s competition book, Of Mice and Men.

This year’s essay subject is Of Mice and Men.

Select one of the following five topics:
For all these questions, use quotations from the text to support your interpretation.

  1. Given George and Lennie’s complex relationship, explain what keeps them together. What does each offer the other?
  1. Will George continue to dream of having a home of his own and “living off the fat of the land” after Lennie’s death? Was this dream ever realistic, with or without Lennie?
  1. Explain the factors that lead to George killing Lennie. Did George have any other choice? Defend your point of view.
  1. Describe Slim’s role in the community of the ranch. What sets him apart from the others? At the end of the novel, why does he alone understand what George has done?
  1. Contrast the relationship of Curly and his wife to that of George and Lennie. Why do both relationships end so tragically?

Official Rules for the Penguin Classics Student Scholarship Essay Contest

No purchase necessary. A purchase will not enhance your opportunity to win.

Open to 9th- and 10th-grade full-time matriculated students who are attending high schools located in the fifty United States and the District of Columbia, or homeschooled students between the ages of 14-16 who are residents of the fifty United States and the District of Columbia.


  1. Matriculated students: Four (4) copies of the essay should be mailed by an English teacher on behalf of the student (each English teacher may submit only one freshman and one sophomore essay). Each of the four (4) copies of the essay should include a cover letter on school letterhead and the following details:
  • Date
  • Student’s full name, grade, address, e-mail and home telephone number
  • Name of high school
  • Name, email and daytime telephone number of English teacher submitting essay (please include summer contact information if different from school year contact information)
  • Name, e-mail and daytime telephone number of the school’s administration officer
  • Topic selected (#1, #2, #3, #4 or #5)
  • Certification by teacher that the essay is the student’s original work.

Essays submitted without a cover letter on school letterhead or cover letters that do not include the above details will be disqualified.

  1. Home-schooled students: Four (4) copies of the essay must be mailed by a parent or legal guardian on behalf of the student. Each of the four (4) copies of the essay should include a cover letter on the parent/legal guardian’s letterhead that certifies that the student is home-schooled and includes the following details:
  • Date
  • Student’s full name, address, e-mail and home telephone number
  • Student’s equivalent grade
  • Name and daytime telephone number and e-mail of the sponsoring parent/legal guardian
  • Topic selected (#1, #2, #3, #4 or #5)
  • Certification by sponsoring parent/legal guardian of home-schooled student that the essay is the student’s original work

Essays submitted without a cover letter on parent/legal guardian’s letterhead or cover letters that do not include the above details will be disqualified.

  1. Essays must be at least two and no more than three double-spaced pages, computer or typewritten (please do not staple submissions). Please include four (4) copies (including four (4) cover letters) of each essay submitted. Entries must be mailed to Penguin Publishing Group, Academic Marketing Department, Penguin Classics Student Scholarship Essay Contest, 375 Hudson Street, New York, NY 10014. To be eligible, all entries must be postmarked by April 28, 2018 and received on or by May 5, 2018. Submissions by fax, email or any other electronic means will not be considered.
  2. Entries will not be returned. By entering the Contest, contestants agree to abide by these rules, and represent and warrant that the entries are their own and original creations, and do not violate or infringe the rights, including, without limitation, copyrights, trademark rights or rights of publicity/privacy, of any third party.
  3. Entries are void if they are in whole or in part illegible, incomplete, damaged or handwritten. No responsibility is assumed for late, lost, damaged, incomplete, illegible, postage due or misdirected mail entries.


All eligible entries received will be judged by a qualified panel of judges chosen by Penguin Publishing Group and winners will be selected on or about June 29, 2018.  Winning essays must demonstrate a comprehensive understanding of the themes and issues presented in Of Mice and Men. Submissions will be judged on style, content, grammar, and originality. Judges will look for clear, concise writing that is original, articulate, logically organized, and well supported.  Winners will be notified by July 8th, 2018 via email, and will be announced online on or about July 15th, 2018.


There are five (5) prizes available to be won. Each prize includes a check in the amount of one thousand dollars ($1,000.00) to be used toward winner’s tuition and/or expenses related to their higher education. Each prize also includes a selection of Penguin Classics Deluxe Editions for the winner’s school library, or public library in the case of a home-schooled winner (Approximate Retail Value (“ARV”) = $TK). Total ARV per prize = $TK.

In the event that there is an insufficient number of qualified entries or if the judges determine in their absolute discretion that no or too few entries meet the quality standards established to award the prizes, Sponsor reserves the right not to award the prizes.


  1. Open to 9th and 10th grade full-time matriculated students who are attending high schools located in the fifty United States and the District of Columbia, or home-schooled students between the ages of 14–16 who are residents of the fifty United States and the District of Columbia. Void where prohibited by law. All state and local restrictions apply.
  2. Employees of Sponsor and its parent company, subsidiaries, affiliates or other parties in any way involved in the development, production or distribution of this Contest, as well as the immediate family (spouse, parents, siblings, children) and household members of each such employee are not eligible to participate in this Contest.

For a copy of the winners list, send a self-addressed, stamped envelope by December 15, 2017 to Penguin Publishing Group, Academic Marketing Department, 375 Hudson Street, New York, NY 10014, Attention: Penguin Classics Student Scholarship Essay Contest #2, or check online after July 15th, 2018.


  1. No cash substitution, transfer or assignment of prizes allowed. In the event of the unavailability of a prize or prizes, Sponsor may substitute a prize or prizes of equal or greater value.
  2. All expenses, including taxes (if any), on receipt and use of prizes are the sole responsibility of the winners.
  3. Winners may be required to execute an Affidavit of Eligibility and Release. The affidavit must be returned within fourteen (14) days of notification or another winner will be selected. If a winner is under 18 years of age, their parent/legal guardian will also be required to sign the Affidavit. Because the ARV exceeds $600.00, winners shall be required to provide a Social Security Number or an Individual Taxpayer Identification Number to Sponsor for issuance of a 1099 Form. The winner’s school library or public library in the case of a home-schooled winner that will receive a selection of Penguin Classics Deluxe Editions shall also be required to provide a Federal Tax Identification Number to Sponsor for issuance of a 1099 form, in connection with its receipt of this portion of the prize.
  4. By accepting a prize, the winners and their parents and/or legal guardians grant to Sponsor the right to edit, publish, copy, display and otherwise use their entries in connection with this Contest, and to further use their names, likenesses, and biographical information in advertising and promotional materials, without further compensation or permission, except where prohibited by law.
  5. LIMITATION OF LIABILITY. By competing in this Contest and/or accepting a prize, entrants release Sponsor, its parent, subsidiary or affiliated companies, or the agencies of any of them and the authors and/or editors of any books promoted hereby from any and all liability for any loss, harm, injuries, damages, cost or expenses arising out of or relating to participation in this Contest or the acceptance, use or misuse of the prize(s). UNDER NO CIRCUMSTANCES SHALL THE RELEASED PARTIES BE LIABLE FOR INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, CONSEQUENTIAL, SPECIAL OR EXEMPLARY DAMAGES, ATTORNEYS’ FEES, OR ANY OTHER DAMAGES.
  6. Any dispute arising from the contest will be determined according to the laws of the state of New York, without reference to its confl ict of law principles, and by entering, the entrants consent to the personal jurisdiction of the state and federal courts located in New York County and agree that such courts have exclusive jurisdiction over all such disputes.


Penguin Publishing Group

Academic Marketing Department

375 Hudson Street, New York, NY 10014

The title for the 3rd Annual Penguin Classics Essay Contest will be The Crucible by Arthur Miller. Essay topics will be posted on our website after July 2018.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *