Hurricane Katrina Case Study Causes Of Diseases

The affected area of Hurricane Katrina covered three states and approximately 90,000 square miles. In the state of Louisiana alone, approximately 1.7 million people were affected by the storm and needed to be evacuated. This was a daunting task that required evacuating the most densely populated area of the state to unaffected regions both within the state and in other states around the country. The state of Louisiana evacuated approximately 1.5 million people before Hurricane Katrina made landfall. However, approximately 150,000 to 200,000 individuals (accurate numbers were difficult to attain) remained during the storm. While many people chose to stay, others did not have an opportunity to evacuate because of unavailable resources, noted Jimmy Guidry of the Louisiana Department of Health and Hospitals.

During the pre- and post-storm evacuation, the state set up special needs shelters for those with medical needs and began triaging approximately 30,000 to 40,000 people. The largest emergency room of 700 beds was established at an assembly center to take care of people from affected areas. Available resources were stretched further when Hurricane Rita made landfall in the Gulf Coast a few weeks after Hurricane Katrina. While Hurricane Katrina affected primarily the eastern part of Louisiana, Hurricane Rita affected the western part. The challenge in responding to Hurricane Rita was that individuals evacuated before Hurricane Katrina to the western part of Louisiana needed to be reevacuated to the eastern and northern parts of the state. Thus, within two hours of the order to evacuate from the path of Hurricane Rita, every remaining gymnasium and every empty space not in the affected area became a shelter, said Guidry.

In the initial days following the storm flooding of Hurricane Katrina, the state evacuated approximately 12,000 caregivers and their patients from 25 hospitals. This was a slow process. In some cases patients were evacuated, one or two at a time, by boat to a helipad where they were transferred to a helicopter that brought them to the airport, from which they were flown to other states. This evacuation of hospital patients to out-of-state locations helped to empty beds and prepared hospitals for attending to victims of the storms.

ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH ISSUES IN NEW ORLEANS AND LOUISIANA

At the time of the workshop, there were still multiple environmental health issues in the area affected by Hurricane Katrina, particularly in New Orleans. A multidisciplinary team comprising both state and federal agencies and workers was formed to address these problems, including (but not limited to) the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), the U.S. Public Health Service, the Louisiana Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ), and the Louisiana Department of Health and Hospitals/Office of Public Health. The environmental issues of concern included the following:

  • Unwatering. Public health service and sanitation professionals in New Orleans were evaluating the quality of the floodwaters that were being pumped into Lake Pontchartrain. They were assessing infectious and chemical agents and evaluating impacts in other areas subject to gravitational unwatering (i.e., draining of the floodwaters). At the same time, a multidisciplinary team of engineers from state and federal agencies was involved in the restoration and improvement of the levee system.

  • Potable water. Public health service and sanitation professionals were monitoring both municipal and community water quality and successfully conveying health warnings when water was not safe to drink.

  • Vector control. Pesticides were being applied to control mosquitoes and flies. The public was notified about aerial applications and disease surveillance. Elimination of standing water and removal and proper disposal of debris were encouraged to deter mosquitoes and flies from multiplying.

  • Safe food. The food supply in food establishments, both retail and wholesale, was being inspected and certified. The handling and disposal of spoiled or contaminated products and ensuring the safety of the commercial seafood harvest were monitored.

  • Waste disposal. Solid waste and debris were being removed, transported, and disposed of. Hazardous materials were isolated for proper disposal, and the debris sites were monitored for environmental exposure by EPA and DEQ.

  • Wastewater systems. Wastewater collection systems were being repaired, rebuilt, and reconfigured. Technical assistance was available from the multidisciplinary teams to all systems, both urban and rural, in the affected region. There was a time after Hurricane Katrina when the sewer disposal system, the pumps, and the treatment center in New Orleans were all submerged in 20 feet of water, said Guidry. Wastewater treatment was a crucial task that needed to be accomplished prior to allowing residents to reinhabit the region.

  • Air quality. Indoor air quality was being monitored, and public health information on proper remediation to homes and businesses was provided. Information was disseminated on mold and dust, proper ways of removing it, what susceptible groups should avoid any exposure, and what appropriate personal protective equipment should be used to limit exposure. According to Guidry, the indoor air quality program in Louisiana had not been a funding priority. Thus, there were many challenges to obtaining and disseminating information on the impact of indoor air quality on residents’ health.

  • Workers’ safety. The safety of workers involved in rebuilding efforts was ensured by providing information on personal protective equipment, vaccines, and proper training and by monitoring illnesses and injuries. If workers got sick or injured, however, there were limited medical resources in New Orleans to provide proper care.

  • Safe housing. Lack of housing for people who wanted to come back to the affected area and rebuild their lives was one of the biggest issues in Louisiana at the time of the workshop. Unlike Texas and Mississippi, Louisiana did not have large supplies of extra temporary housing. The state government calculated that there was a need for approximately 100,000 trailers to house people. Moving from large shelters to trailer homes may affect people’s mental health, as they will have to integrate into a new community and environment.

  • Recreation. Recreational activities such as boating, swimming, fishing, hunting, camping, and bird watching were a part of the state’s natural resources in the Gulf Coast prior to Hurricanes Katrina and Rita. The entire coastline affected by the two storms was being monitored, and information on the potential impacts was being provided.

According to Guidry, it was important for people to get back to a sense of normalcy and to move on with their lives as soon as possible. People who were trying to come back to the affected area and rebuild needed to know the risks they were taking. To provide proper risk communication, it was critical to educate health care providers about environmental issues and to ensure their understanding of the science so that they could knowledgeably explain to people the possible environmental impacts of Hurricane Katrina on their health. This task was impeded by the lack of workforce and infrastructure as a result of the storms. Prior to Hurricane Katrina, New Orleans was a mecca in the state for medical care, with one-third of public health employees (450) working in the central Office of Public Health in New Orleans, said Guidry. Many health care facilities, including the downtown Office of Public Health, were closed after the storm, and at the time of the workshop, only 200 of the central Office of Public Health employees in New Orleans had reported back to work.

The economic impact of the storm will change the future of the entire country, asserted Guidry. Prior to the storm, the city was one of the largest ports in the country. The damage from the storm will impact the city’s provision of seafood and tourism—two key components of the local economy. Still, Guidry noted, the destruction may be an opportunity to rebuild Louisiana into a better place and even to lead the country in deciding how to contend with health care for everyone, including the indigent.

The economic impact of the storm will change the future of the entire country.

—Jimmy Guidry

CHALLENGES AND NEEDS FOR HEALTH IN NEW ORLEANS

The City of New Orleans Health Department’s mission is to protect, promote, and enhance health status; to advocate and support health maintenance; to develop health policy; and to map diseases and manage their prevention. The department’s goals are to increase the quality and the longevity of the public’s life and to eliminate health disparities, said Kevin Stephens, Director of Health of the New Orleans Health Department. After Hurricanes Katrina and Rita, New Orleans Health Department officials faced many challenges associated with flooding, environmental exposure assessment and monitoring, and infrastructure rebuilding. The city’s public health officials interpreted the exposure data received from scientists for the general population and worked on determining how to protect and ensure the safety of the people who chose to return to their homes.

Sediment Data in New Orleans

Hurricane Katrina inundated New Orleans with contaminated floodwaters, making the city a unique toxic dump site. Through sediment testing it was determined that lead, arsenic, chromium, and copper values exceeded the levels for direct ingestion (EPA, 2005b). Petroleum hydrocarbons were detected in some samples; however, they were not widespread but limited to localized areas (EPA, 2005b). Metals, semivolatiles, and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, related to wood-treating activities as well as pesticides from termite control efforts, were also found in the sediment. Among other components found in the sediment were organic compounds and heavy metals, including mercury; however, their levels were below what the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR) considers to be immediately hazardous to human health, noted Stephens. Lead levels detected in the sediment were similar to pre-Katrina levels, said Stephens. This is not surprising given the age of the New Orleans housing stock and the fact that some of the houses still had lead-based paints.

EPA and ATSDR concluded that exposures to floodwaters and sediment at these levels during the response activities were not expected to cause adverse health effects as long as the proper protective equipment was worn. The agencies recommended avoiding, whenever possible, all contact with sediment deposited by the floodwaters because of potential concerns associated with long-term skin contact. They also recommended that responders wear personal protective equipment, such as gloves and safety glasses.

Among other components found in the sediment were organic compounds and heavy metals, including mercury; however, their levels were below what ATSDR considers to be immediately hazardous to human health.

—Kevin Stephens

Findings of Environmental Surveillance in New Orleans

In the immediate aftermath of a disaster, there is the potential for increased incidence of infectious diseases. To monitor this, the New Orleans Health Department conducted an environmental survey at all the hospitals, emergency rooms, and local ambulatory clinical sites in the city. Because E. coli from exposure to contaminated floodwaters was a concern, the city’s public health officials conducted a survey of patients with diarrhea.

The survey data showed that both watery and bloody diarrhea decreased significantly over time (Figure 3-1). Because of the risk of mold and particulate matter in the air, public health officials in New Orleans also conducted a survey on acute respiratory illnesses. Initially, there was a rise in respiratory illnesses, and the department together with CDC launched a full-fledged investigation of those cases. Close analysis suggested that some members of a disaster medical assistance team had viral infections that spread from the group. Precautionary measures such as washing hands were taken, and after the intervention the rates declined, said Stephens.

FIGURE 3-1

Because E. coli from exposure to contaminated floodwaters was a concern, the city’s public health officials conducted a survey of patients with diarrhea. The survey data showed that both watery and bloody diarrhea decreased significantly over (more...)

Surveillance on unintentional injuries, such as motor vehicle crashes, animal bites, and bee stings, was also conducted. It showed that as the floodwaters receded and the disaster-affected areas were cleaned up, most of the threats, such as debris on streets, dark streets, and vermin living in brush piles, slowly resolved themselves.

Questions and Challenges for the New Orleans Health Department

The New Orleans Health Department still has a number of questions that need to be answered, said Stephens.

  • What is the long-term risk associated with exposure?

  • What specific monitoring methodologies should be used?

  • What should be monitored, what are the biomarkers, and how often should monitoring occur?

  • What precautions should be taken to eliminate risks and adverse effects? If the risks cannot be eliminated, how can their effects be reduced?

  • What are the appropriate communication strategies and messages?

The last question is very important because public health officers need to reassure the public. False reassurance would serve no purpose and could impede the recovery, cautioned Stephens.

In conclusion, Stephens noted that unintentional injuries seemed to be the predominant problem in New Orleans, and no evidence of infectious disease outbreaks was found. He also noted that protective measures should be taken and that the New Orleans Health Department will continue to monitor data.

The Health Effects of Hurricane Katrina

Author: Brianna Frank

Storm track map from NASA, showing the increase in surface water caused by Hurricane Katrina (left) and Rita (right). (http://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/hurricanes/archives/2005/h2005_katrina.html)

This case study is part of a collection of pages developed by students in the 2012 introductory-level Geology and Human Health course in the Department of Earth Sciences, Montana State University. Learn more about this project.

Hurricane Katrina was one of the strongest storms to hit the United States coast within the last 100 years. It devastated New Orleans and caused many health concerns for the public. The water left from the storm left little clean water to use, buildings completely destroyed, and the public at a loss for words. Nothing can truly stop these types of storms, all one can do is know what to look out for and how to protect themselves as best as they can.

Hurricane Katrina

Hurricanes are natural disasters that have unfortunately been on the rise as the years have gone on. With any natural disaster, comes concerns for human health. Hurricane Katrina brought with it flood waters, the loss of power, little livable space left, and a breeding ground for mosquitoes. This in turn caused molds to grow, endotoxin levels to rise, little clean drinking water, spoiled food, West Nile virus concerns, and many other causes for a person to be sick. New Orleans, Louisiana was devastated by Hurricane Katrina. Close to 90 percent of the city was flooded, some parts of the city under 20 feet of water. Many structures were completely destroyed and those that weren't destroyed by the hurricane, most likely had to be destroyed because of how long the flood waters were there. The pumps used to rid the city of the water, were not working and because they couldn't be replaced, had to be repaired. This led to the integrity of the buildings to be compromised, leaving people homeless and worries to arise about the places refugees were going to stay when the water was all pumped out of the city.

A look at Hurricane Katrina before it hits land near New Orleans. The colors in the image so the the intensity of the storm. You can visibly see the eye of the storm. Picture from NOAA. (http://www.vos.noaa.gov/MWL/apr_06/katrina.shtml)

Katrina's Path

Katrina began about 200 miles southeast of Nassau in the Bahamas. It then moved northwest, becoming Tropical Storm Katrina. It continued through the northwestern Bahamas (August 24-25) and then went westward towards southern Florida. Tropical Storm Katrina became Hurricane Katrina just before it made landfall near the Miami-Dade/Broward county line (August 25). It then moved southwest across southern Florida and into the eastern Gulf of Mexico (August 26). The center made landfall near Buras, Louisiana (August 29) and continued north. It was still a hurricane near Laurel, Mississippi, but became a tropical depression over the Tennessee Valley (August 30). It continued up to the Great Lakes, weakening until it became a frontal zone (August 31).

Health Effects of Hurricane Katrina

The main health effects of Hurricane Katrina had to deal with the amount of water left behind in New Orleans. Outbreaks of West Nile, mold, and endotoxin levels rising were the biggest concerns. With the flooding came all new types of bacteria from the open water, leaving New Orleans with little to defend itself. The medical centers were either destroyed or in utter disarray and power was lost for quite awhile. The concern that people were going to get sick because of contaminated food or water also weighed heavily on people's minds. All of the health concerns for New Orleans came from the amount of flood water because there was so much of it, that it was an optimal breeding ground for mosquitoes and the water covered everything making nothing truly safe.

The image above shows the pumping of water out of New Orleans. The darker areas are the flood waters and the dates under the pictures show the progress made to rid the city of the water. Picture from NASA. (http://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/hurricanes/archives/2005/h2005_katrina.html)

Here is a link to the NOAA (National Oceanic And Atmospheric Administration) site on Hurricane Katrina and a few impacts Katrina had in the south United States. Hurricane Katrina.

Clean Up

The clean up for Hurricane Katrina is still on going. A lot of water flooded the city and some areas that were flooded near New Orleans are still under water. Those areas may just become lakes because the water may never drain out. New Orleans had to fix their water pumps in order to drain their city. This took a few days because they couldn't replace them since the pumps they did have, weren't manufactured anymore. The extra time it took to repair the pumps meant that the city stayed in the dirty water that much longer. This meant that most homes that were flooded had to be completely destroyed. The foundations were weakened and more and more mold was growing. The city was going to be uninhabitatable longer and longer. The levees also had to be repaired to keep the water out of the city. When the water was finally pumped out, the homes had to be taken care of. The people of the city were put in temporary trailers while their homes were destroyed and then reconstructed. Every home that was flooded, had to be destroyed because it sat too long, too much mold and putrid water sat within them. Once the homes were cleared and power was restored, the concerns for human health went down considerably. Clean water and food were brought in while the plants that filtered the water were being repaired and power was restored.

Effects Hurricane Katrina Had on the Rest of the U.S.

Katrina hit New Orleans the hardest, mainly because it is below sea level and easily flooded, but it also did damage in other states. It caused flooding in Southern Florida and damage and extensive power outages in Miami. From the Gulf coast to the Ohio Valley, flood watches and warnings were issued. Parts of Biloxi and Gulfport, Mississippi were under water. Some rain bands from Katrina also produced tornadoes creating more damage. Some areas effected by the tornadoes were in Georgia. Most of the death toll though, was in Mississippi and Louisiana, but a few deaths were also reported in Florida. The entire U.S. was also affected when the oil rigs in the Gulf were found to have suffered major damages, making gas prices go up.

Pathway Katrina followed before and after Katrina hit land. You see the areas in Louisiana she crossed over. Picture from NOAA. (http://www.vos.noaa.gov/MWL/apr_06/katrina.shtml)

Prevention

In order to prevent more disasterous floods in New Orleans, better levees have been built and a better disaster plan has been made. Unfortunately, because New Orleans is below sea level completely preventing a disaster like this is not possible. New Orleans will continue to sink and flooding will always be a problem. Better, faster clean up is the only way that the city can prevent a disaster as great as Hurricane Katrina. Routine maintenance of the pumps and levees can help keep the water at bay, but one day it will return. Fast action, awareness, and knowledge of a disaster plan are the only things that people can do to protect themselves. Those and flood insurance, will help to make sure people stay safe. Also, when a city is evacuated for a hurricane make sure to secure your home and then evacuate yourself.

Recommended Readings

"Effect of Hurricane Katrina on New Orleans." Angelfire. N.p., 2005. Web. Sept. 2012. http://www.angelfire.com/ia3/katrina/neworleans.htm

This website covers what was done in New Orleans before and after Hurricane Katrina. It also talks about the different problems that arose and how they were taken care of. This is a reliable, objective source that discusses the events of Hurricane Katrina in New Orleans. It was very useful in discussing the specific effects Hurricane Katrina had on New Orleans and how the hurricane was handled there.

Used sites:

National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (last accessed 12/10/12):

This website gives an account of what happen before, during, and after Hurricane Katrina.

This website tells of the path Hurricane Katrina took and the effects Katrina had on certain areas.

This website is an overview of the weather side of Hurricane Katrina and how that effected the areas Katrina passed over.

National Center of Biotechnology Information (last accessed 12/10/12):

This website about the procedure people took to check their homes for mold and check the endotoxin levels to make sure they're home was safe.

Environmental Protection Agency (last accessed 12/10/12):

The website tells about the health problems facing New Orleans and how to deal with them.

Effects of Hurricane Katrina on New Orleans (last accessed 12/10/12):

This website tells about the predictions given for Katrina and then what actually happened and how everything was taken care of.

National Aeronautics and Space Administration (last accessed 12/10/12):

This website gives an overview of what happened and what was done to deal with the effects.

0 comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *